"Honor thy father and thy mother." That is scripture. It's true. It's a commandment. And it can also be used in one of the most un-Christlike ways imaginable.
There's a massive difference between using scripture to guide someone toward God and using scripture to pressure someone into giving you what you want. If you've ever tried to set a boundary with a religious family, you may know exactly what I mean. You finally said, "This relationship is hurting me," or "We're going to make a different decision for our marriage and our children." And instead of being heard, someone reached for scripture: "Honor your father and mother." "Forgive seventy times seven." "Blessed are the peacemakers." "Families are forever." "Don't create contention."
Suddenly you're no longer talking about what happened. You're defending whether you're a good Christian. That's spiritual manipulation, and in deeply religious families it can be incredibly hard to recognize.
Watch the full Cleave Answers video below.
When Religious Language Is Aimed Only at the Person Who Was Hurt
For years, Ashley and I believed many of the same things a lot of people of faith believe. If you love your family, you stay. You forgive, overlook, and give people the benefit of the doubt. You try harder and become more patient, humble, and Christlike. Those are beautiful instincts.
But eventually we noticed something. When harmful behavior happened, the religious language was directed almost exclusively at the person who was hurt, not the person causing the harm. The person who was hurt was told to forgive, to keep the peace, to honor their parents, to watch out for bitterness.
Eventually you have to ask: Why are we using scripture to manage the response to the behavior instead of using scripture to confront the behavior itself? That question changes everything, because dysfunctional family systems often take a true principle and apply it in a way that protects the system. Here's how.
1. Scripture Becomes a Conversation Stopper
One of the easiest ways to recognize spiritual manipulation is that the scripture isn't being used to deepen the conversation. It's being used to end it.
"Mom, that hurt me." / "Honor thy father and thy mother." Conversation over.
"I need some distance right now." / "Jesus told us to forgive seventy times seven." Conversation over.
"I don't think this is healthy for our children." / "But families are forever." Conversation over.
Nobody addressed your concern. Nobody asked what happened, why you feel unsafe, what could be done differently, or whether there's something that needs repentance. The religious principle was used to bypass the actual issue.
Truth should be able to survive questions. Jesus wasn't afraid of difficult conversations. He asked questions, confronted hypocrisy, exposed motives, and invited repentance. When scripture becomes a way of saying "you're not allowed to question this," we've stopped using it as truth and started using it as leverage.
2. They Quote the Verse That Applies to You and Ignore the One That Applies to Them
Take "Honor thy father and thy mother." Beautiful commandment. But in Ephesians, just after Paul tells children to obey their parents, he tells fathers, "provoke not your children to wrath" (Ephesians 6:4). Why don't we quote that part?
Scripture places responsibility on both sides of every relationship: parents and children, husbands and wives, leaders and followers. But dysfunctional systems love one-directional scripture. It always seems to apply to the person who needs to comply, never to the person who needs to change.
Someone may say, "You need to forgive me seventy times seven." Maybe. But where is the conversation about repentance, confession, restitution, and turning away from destructive behavior? Forgiveness is Christian. So are repentance, truth, and accountability. When someone consistently wants the verses about your obligation to forgive but has little interest in the verses about their obligation to repent, pay attention. That isn't a balanced use of scripture. It's selective theology used to preserve access.
3. Peace Gets Redefined as "Keep Everyone Comfortable"
This may be the biggest trap for people who grew up in religious families. Jesus said, "Blessed are the peacemakers" (Matthew 5:9). So when conflict happens, good people immediately think: I need to make this stop. I need to calm Mom down, make Dad happy, go to Thanksgiving, respond to that text, explain myself again, apologize, smooth things over.
But peacemaking and appeasement aren't the same thing. Sometimes maintaining peace with everyone else requires creating chaos inside yourself. You're anxious. Your marriage is strained. Your spouse feels abandoned. Your kids feel the tension. You spend three days recovering from every phone call. But everyone else is happy because you're still playing your role, and somehow we call that peace. It isn't. It's compliance.
Romans offers a fascinating qualification: "If it be possible, as much as lieth in you, live peaceably with all men" (Romans 12:18). If it be possible. As much as lieth in you. Peace is relational. You can't single-handedly create a healthy relationship with someone who refuses to participate in one. You can control whether you retaliate, gossip, become cruel, or pursue revenge. You can't control whether another person takes accountability. Sometimes the most peaceful option available to you is distance. Not punishment or revenge. Distance.
4. Forgiveness Gets Turned Into Unlimited Access
This may be one of the most damaging theological ideas floating around families: the belief that if you truly forgive someone, everything should return to normal. No.
Forgiveness and reconciliation aren't identical. Forgiveness and trust aren't identical. Forgiveness and access aren't identical. You can forgive someone and still say, "I'm not ready to have you in my home." "We're not discussing our marriage with you anymore." "My children won't be placed in that situation again." You can forgive someone, decline Christmas dinner, and pray for them while recognizing the relationship still isn't safe.
Jesus Himself didn't give everyone equal access to Him. John tells us He "did not commit himself unto them, because he knew all men" (John 2:24). He withdrew from crowds. He allowed people to walk away. He didn't chase everyone down saying, "Wait, you're upset with me? Let me explain until you approve." He was deeply loving, compassionate, and forgiving, and completely unafraid of boundaries.
Forgiveness changes what I carry.
Reconciliation requires something from both of us.
Trust is rebuilt through behavior.
Access is a stewardship decision.
When someone tells you Christianity requires all four instantly because you said you forgive them, they're asking scripture to say something it doesn't say.
5. Your Relationship With God Gets Used Against You
This is where spiritual manipulation becomes especially painful, because now the threat isn't just "Mom is angry with you." It's "God is disappointed in you." That's an incredibly powerful lever for someone who genuinely loves God.
"I don't know how you can feel good about this spiritually." "You should really pray about what you're doing." "God would never tell you to separate from your family." "Satan wants to divide families." Suddenly your family disagreement has become a referendum on your relationship with God, and even a very emotionally healthy person can start to wonder: Maybe I'm selfish. Maybe this boundary is sinful. Maybe I'm being deceived.
Here's something I want to say carefully: nobody gets to take over your relationship with God. Not your parents, siblings, a therapist, an influencer, or me. Your spiritual life requires humility, prayer, study, self-examination, and a willingness to be corrected. Absolutely. But someone else's discomfort doesn't automatically equal divine revelation. "I don't like your decision" and "God doesn't like your decision" are not the same sentence.
How to Tell Sincere Faith From Weaponized Scripture
1. Is this scripture being applied to everyone, or only to me?
If I'm told to forgive, is the other person being invited to repent? If I'm told to honor, is the parent being invited to act honorably? If I'm told to seek peace, is everyone being asked to stop the behavior that's destroying it?
2. Does it open the door to truth, or shut it?
Can I still talk about what happened? Ask questions? Disagree? Say that something hurt me?
3. Does the interpretation preserve agency?
God invites, teaches, warns, and commands. But healthy spirituality never requires one person to surrender their conscience to another.
4. What is the fruit?
Jesus gave us this test Himself: "by their fruits ye shall know them" (Matthew 7:20). Does this religious pressure produce humility, repentance, truth, love, patience, accountability, and repair? Or fear, shame, secrecy, control, confusion, anxiety, and silence? The fruit tells you something.
The Irony: "Leave and Cleave" Is Scripture Too
People sometimes weaponize scripture to defend family unity while ignoring one of the earliest instructions scripture gives about family: "a man shall leave his father and his mother, and shall cleave unto his wife" (Genesis 2:24).
Marriage creates a new primary family unit. That doesn't mean parents, siblings, or grandparents stop mattering. But something changes. Your spouse is no longer an outsider asking permission to join your family. You created a family. When extended family repeatedly destabilizes that marriage, using scripture to demand loyalty to the original family system can actually contradict the very biblical order they claim to defend.
That was one of the hardest things for Ashley and me to understand. We weren't trying to reject faith. We were trying to live it. We weren't trying to destroy family. We were trying to protect the family we were responsible for. Eventually we realized the teachings of Jesus weren't the problem. The way those teachings were being used was.
You Don't Have to Abandon Your Faith to Recognize Spiritual Manipulation
That realization was incredibly freeing. Sometimes your faith is precisely what helps you recognize manipulation, because Christ never used truth to dominate people. He used truth to make them free (John 8:32). He didn't protect appearances at the expense of integrity. He didn't confuse love with unlimited access. He didn't chase everyone who rejected Him. And He never taught that keeping another person comfortable was the highest form of righteousness.
So if someone has used scripture against you, don't throw the scripture away. Read more of it. Read the verse before and the verse after. Study the life of Jesus. Look at the fruit. Ask what repentance, truth, and love actually require.
Sometimes the most dangerous spiritual manipulation contains a lot of truth. It's just truth removed from context and aimed in one direction. Scripture wasn't given so we could control other people. It was given to transform us. So when someone quotes a verse at you, the question isn't only "Is that verse true?" It may absolutely be true. The question is: How is this truth being used? Is it drawing both of us toward Christ, or is it being used to get me back into my assigned role?
You can stay deeply committed to your faith while refusing to participate in unhealthy family patterns. You can forgive without pretending, love without surrendering wisdom, honor people without giving them control over your marriage, seek peace without abandoning truth, and follow Jesus without letting someone use His name to manipulate you.
Keep Reading
A Resource for People Walking Through This
If scripture has been used to pressure you into silence or unlimited access, Ashley and I wrote Christlike Boundaries for you. It's about how to love truthfully without betraying what God has entrusted to you, and how to tell the difference between real faith and spiritual pressure.
You can read the Introduction and Chapter 1 free here:
Get the free chapter of Christlike Boundaries
And if you want to walk through this with people of faith who understand, the Cleave Community includes weekly live Q&A with Ashley and me, small faith-centered support groups, and the full Christlike Boundaries course.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it a sin to set boundaries with my parents?
No. Honoring your parents isn't the same as giving them unlimited access or control. Jesus Himself withdrew, said no, and "did not commit himself" to everyone (John 2:24). You can speak respectfully, forgive, and pray for your parents while still limiting your participation in harmful patterns.
Does forgiveness mean I have to let them back into my life?
No. Forgiveness changes what you carry. Reconciliation requires something from both people, trust is rebuilt through behavior, and access is a stewardship decision. You can forgive someone and still need distance.
What is spiritual manipulation in a family?
It's using scripture or religious language to end conversations, avoid accountability, or pressure someone into compliance, often by applying verses only to the person who was hurt and implying God disapproves of their boundaries.
How do I respond when my family quotes "honor thy father and mother"?
You can affirm the principle while separating honor from access: "I do want to honor you, and this is still what we need right now." It can also help to remember that scripture places responsibilities on parents too, such as "provoke not your children to wrath" (Ephesians 6:4).
How can I tell if scripture is being used sincerely or as a weapon?
Ask whether it's applied to everyone or only to you, whether it opens or shuts the door to truth, whether it preserves your agency, and what fruit it produces. Humility, repentance, and repair point one way. Fear, shame, secrecy, and control point another.